Reflections on the Twisted Nether Blogcast

Fortunately, the talkative Cyn showed up to last weeks’ Twisted Nether Blogcast. Fimlys and Nibuca were gracious enough to let me go on at some length about battlegrounds, Children’s Week, professions, blogging – and put up with my terrible jokes. I had a great time and hope they did too. I hope you enjoy listening to it either on their site, or downloaded into your podcast software of choice.

One of the challenges with recording an interview is making sure that you’re accurate while also maintaining the flow of the conversation.  I made a few outright errors that I’d like to correct now, while there are a few topics I’d like to expand further upon in later blog posts.

Yes.  I’m issuing an errata for an interview.  I’ve done stranger things.

I’ll update this post with corrections as they come to light.  It’s a long interview, so let me know if there’s something else I need to update.

Once again, thanks to Fimlys and Nibuca for having me as a guest on their show.

WINTERGRASP

I said that the Horde controls Wintergrasp 25-35% of the time on Durotan.  According to Time Until Wintergrasp (the site I mentioned I couldn’t remember), the ratio on Durotan for May 2010 was 168-93 for the Alliance, or a 36% Horde win rate.

TOL BARAD

I stated, quite confidently, that the name of the upcoming Cataclysm PvP zone Tol Barad is taken directly from Tolkien. That part I stand behind. I was completely wrong in saying that there is a specific location in Tolkien’s work named Tol Barad, specifically the island in the River Sirion in ancient Beleriand. This island is called Tol Sirion, upon which stood the original Minas Tirith. (The Minas Tirith in Gondor that appears in The Lord of the Rings is named after this Noldor fortification.)  This island was overrun by the forces of Morgoth led by Sauron (yes, that Sauron) and renamed Tol-in-Gaurhoth, the Isle of Werewolves.

You can insert your own Worgen joke here, if you like.

Fimlys was quite right that Tol Brandir, the island above the great Falls of Rauros on the River Anduin in LotR, is closest in sound to Tol Barad. Barad does appear in several place names, most famously Barad-dûr, the fortress of Sauron in Mordor, but also in Barad Eithel, the fortress of Fingolfin, and Barad Nimras, the sea-watchtower of Finrod.

In my head I had conflated Tol Sirion and Barad Eithel, which are geographically close but not identical.  Sorry about that!

In Sindarin, Tol translates to “island” and Barad to “tower.” So if we attempt a translation of Tol Barad, it would be “the Island of the Tower,” “Tower Island,” or perhaps “The Fortified Isle.”

All of those are good enough names for a battleground, though Tower Island sounds a little cheesy and there’s already an Isle of Conquest. So while I find the name jarring (much like Prince Anduin) I can live with it.

It bugged me that I got this one wrong. I love Tolkien’s works and hate when I accidentally spread misinformation.


About these ads

9 Comments

Filed under Cynwise's Battlefield Manual

9 responses to “Reflections on the Twisted Nether Blogcast

  1. jealouspirate

    I just finished listening to the podcast. Pretty interesting! Covered a lot more than battlegrounds. This post made me laugh.. thanks for the correction!

  2. Just listening to the interview now. Huh. I never thought you were a girl. Who cares anyway? It’s all about melting face!

    • I thought about doing a longer post on gender identity in PvP and blogging. It was the first topic in the interview, and I was still pretty tense so there were a few points I didn’t make that I thought I wanted to.

      But then I sit back and go, no, it’s really not that important. I write from a gender-neutral viewpoint because honestly? I don’t think it matters in PvP. Or in much else, but this blog is about PvP so there we have it.

      And that doesn’t make for a very long article. :-)

  3. I’m still listening… I think you’re catching the hosts of the show off guard.

    What is this PVP thing you speak of?

    How is it possible to look at your map so long that you’re flagged /afk? *boggle*

    And I thought I was a PVP noob.

  4. Dolar

    Cyn, you crack me up:)

    Not get to it, I was to see what you think about the new BG Twin Peaks already :) WSG version 2.0, should be fun:)

  5. I thought you came across very knowledgable and well informed in the interview Cyn. I enjoyed it and I hope we get more of your pearls of wisdom to listen to soon!